Plastic. Fantastic?

Can we learn to live with (and even love) plastic?
IN THE 1850s, the titans of the American billiards industry faced a vexing problem. A mere eight balls could be carved from the tusks of a large Asian elephant, but the species, once populous, had been hunted into near extinction—a casualty of the demand for ivory for everything from cue balls to corsets. Fearing the parlor game's demise, manufacturer Michael Phelan offered a $10,000 reward to anyone who could create an artificial material that mimicked ivory's unusual mix of pliability and durability. "If any inventive genius would discover a substitute for ivory, possessing those qualities which make it valuable to the billiard player, he would make a handsome fortune for himself, and earn our sincerest gratitude," Phelan pleaded. When a New York chemist named John Wesley Hyatt subsequently debuted a synthetic ivory pool ball made from a compound called celluloid, it was lauded as revolutionary. Plastic had arrived, ready to save the planet.
More than 150 years later, the story could hardly be more different. As the most visible evidence of a disposable, trash-addled society, plastic has become the emblem of a world swimming in waste. Reportedly, plastic shopping bags are used an average of just 12 minutes before being thrown away. Every year, more than 500 billion plastic bags are discarded worldwide; they wave from tree branches so abundantly that South Africans have dubbed them their "national flower," and no fewer than six countries have enacted bans. Shredded packaging fouls shorelines and turns up in the stomachs of trout, albatross, and sea turtles (which mistake plastic bags for jellyfish). In the Pacific Ocean, currents feed scraps into a thousand-mile-wide gyre of synthetic jetsam. (See Where Plastics Go to Kill.)
Advertisement
Advertisement
Plastic's capacity for near-infinite proliferation initially seemed like a boon. Compared with wood or metal, it was seen as "an infinite material," notes Jeffrey Meikle, the author of American Plastic: A Cultural History. Originally made from coal tar, the waste produced by coking coal for incineration, plastic used almost no extra resources and yet could be churned out by the ton. "It was a striking innovation," Meikle says. "From the scrap heap of industry, you could create essentially as much plastic as you want."
And therein lay the rub. Inexpensive to make and easy to discard, plastic morphed from an engineering triumph into a global scourge. In 1960, Americans sent 390,000 tons of plastics to the landfill; today we annually trash more than 28.5 million tons—around 11 percent of all municipal waste. Plastic doesn't biodegrade, and the very characteristic that makes it so versatile—its protean ability to be resilient or stiff, soft or hard, opaque or transparent—makes it extremely difficult to recycle efficiently. Even the most common recyclable categories of plastic (No. 1 water bottles, for instance) consist of incompatible polymers with different melting points. In 2007, less than 7 percent of Americans' plastic waste was recycled (mostly milk jugs and water and soda bottles), as opposed to 55 percent of paper.
A 2000 survey by the American Chemistry Council (ACC) found that fewer than half of Americans had a positive opinion of the miracle material; 25 percent "strongly believed" that plastic's environmental negatives outweighed its benefits. The industry claims the ratings have improved, though it declines to release new data.
Even loyalists admit that plastic has an image problem. When I asked Robert Krebs, spokesman for the ACC, for ways in which plastic has benefited the environment, he sent me a digital dump of documents and studies—everything from an EPA review asserting the superiority of plastic grocery bags over paper (they take less energy to produce and transport, and consume fewer resources) to a report on the fuel savings from plastic car parts. But Krebs sounded glum when he contemplated plastic's pariah reputation. "Fifty percent popularity puts you down there with the trial lawyers," he said with a tired sigh. For a popular material, plastic is remarkably unpopular.
Yet there is still a case to be made for plastic. In the spring of 1980, a young researcher at the Worldwatch Institute named Christopher Flavin published a 55-page report titled "The Future of Synthetic Materials." Obscure as it was, the paper created a stir. Flavin challenged the environmentalist dogma that plastic was an ecological disaster and was bleeding the country of large amounts of petroleum—in the midst of an oil crisis, no less. In fact, Flavin argued, plastics were uncommonly efficient, often taking less energy to produce than the materials, like aluminum and glass, that they replaced. And plastics were relatively thrifty, energy-wise. (Today, 120 billion pounds of plastic are generated each year using less than 5 percent of world oil supplies. In the United States, most plastic is made with natural gas, using about 5.6 percent of our gas output.) Moreover, plastics begat other savings, Flavin noted. They made packaging lighter, reducing the amount of fuel needed for shipping, and preserved food more effectively, meaning less breakage and waste. Plastic window tinting reduced the use of air conditioning, while spray foam insulation minimized heat loss.
Now the president of Worldwatch, Flavin has moderated his opinion of plastic. He now worries about toxicity (the carcinogens in PVC and additives such as bisphenol-A in food-grade plastics, for instance), plastics in the ocean, and solid waste, a byproduct of the "massive throwaway culture" that he believes plastics have engendered. Nonetheless, he still considers synthetics "one of the higher and better uses for oil," especially on the carbon front. "It's a better value for the material," he explains. "You're not throwing carbon into the atmosphere"—because making plastic doesn't burn oil—"and the quantities are so much smaller than what we use for transportation. My guess would be that we'll end up using oil for synthetic materials long after we stop using it for basic combustion." Though he'd like to see us use a lot less plastic, Flavin recognizes that there aren't always sustainable alternatives. "It would certainly be very difficult to live a plastic-free life today," he says. "It's in so many things. But there are a lot of problems with natural materials, too. There's really no bright line between 'natural is good' and 'synthetic is bad.' The world is more complicated than that." We may be stuck with plastic, but sometimes it may be the lesser evil.
However, plastic requires more than just an image makeover if it's going to make a positive contribution to a more energy efficient, less disposable world. "I think the case is fairly clear that we need to stop wasting petroleum for single-use products, like plastic bags and water bottles that get used for a few minutes and discarded," says Allen Hershkowitz, a senior scientist with the Natural Resources Defense Council. "What's less clear is what we do next, and how we do it in a cost-competitive and ecologically sound way."
The solution may be for plastic to keep doing what it does best—evolving, in essence, to become a better substitute for its current form. Flavin has hopes for the next generation of compostable plastics, like the corn-based plastic that's turning up in cutlery and food packaging. These "natural" plastics are less toxic to produce and more easily disposed of, yet they still have complicated environmental lives. (See "Infinite Pest.") Many plastics labeled as biodegradable will break down only in high-heat commercial composting facilities, not if they're put in backyard composts or just left to the elements. Nonetheless, when they're disposed of properly, bioplastics easily beat conventional plastics on the waste front. Future generations of bioplastics made from agricultural waste and produced with renewable energy could even be carbon negative.
The quest for the 21st century's artificial ivory cue ball—a plastic that's "nontoxic, totally biodegradable, easily recycled," as Flavin puts it—has a long way to go. Market analysts estimate that it could be another 20 years before bioplastics make up even 5 percent of the global plastics market. Yet Hershkowitz says demand, and rising oil costs, will push companies like DuPont and BASF to pursue alternatives. "The writing's on the wall for this," he says. "And that's a good thing."
The key, explains Flavin, is to focus not solely on what new plastics will be used for, but where they will go when they're thrown away, and then engineer them to break down accordingly. Making plastics whose final feat is to disappear without a trace, he says, "will be a complex engineering challenge that will keep many people employed for years to come."
Comments
Turning Plastic into Oil
the large supermarkets have
the large supermarkets have stoppped giving out plastic bags unless specifically asked to do so. Instead they encourage customers to use recyclable "greener" bags and offer more incentives for customers to stop using plastic bags. Hopefully as time goes on, the reliance on plastic bags will diminish.
Cheap Computers Parts Cheap
Cheap Computers Parts
Cheap Digital Cameras
Plantronics Plantronics .Audio 326
Plantronics Plantronics .Audio 655 USB
Plantronics Plantronics .Audio 995
ZOWIE ZOWIE HAMMER e SPORT HEADSET
HP Pavilion P6330F Desktop PC Black
HP Pavilion Elite HPE 110F Desktop PC Black
HP Pavilion Elite HPE 120F Desktop PC Black
SMART BUY XW9400 OPT 2376 Desktop Computer
HP Z400 Desktop Workstation FL863UT
SMART BUY FL906UT ABA Z600 TWR W3503 Desktop Computer
HP Pavilion P6320F Desktop PC Black
SMART BUY FL879UT ABA Z800 TWR X5550 Desktop Computer
SMART BUY FL877UT ABA Z800 TWR E5520 Desktop Computer
HP Pavilion Elite HPE 140F Desktop PC Black
HP Z800 Desktop Workstation FL884UT
SMART BUY FL867UT ABA Z600 TWR E5504 Desktop Computer
SMART BUY FL880UT ABA Z800 TWR X5560 Desktop Computer
SMART BUY FL872UT ABA Z600 TWR X5570 Desktop Computer
SMART BUY XW9400 OPT 2380 Desktop Computer
SMART BUY FL878UT ABA Z800 TWR E5530 Desktop Computer
SMART BUY FL881UT ABA Z800 TWR W5580 Desktop Computer
SMART BUY FL873UT ABA Z600 TWR X5570 Desktop Computer
SMART BUY FL871UT ABA Z600 TWR X5550 Desktop Computer
SMART BUY FL870UT ABA Z600 TWR E5540 Desktop Computer
SMART BUY FL904UT ABA Z800 TWR E5506 Desktop Computer
Smart Buy T5720 NX1500 512 512 Tc
SMART BUY Z400 FL885UT ABA TWR W3503 Desktop Computer
HP Z800 Desktop Workstation FL875UT
SMART BUY FL864UT ABA Z400 TWR W3540 Desktop Computer
HP Promo XW4600 E5200 160 2GB NVS290 Ws US English Localization
SMART BUY FL903UT ABA Z600 TWR E5506 Desktop Computer
SMART BUY FL827UT ABA Xw4600 E8400 Desktop Computer
HP J8433A ABA 6 Port 10Gbps Ethernet Switch
HP Z600 Desktop Workstation FL868UT
HP Z400 Desktop Workstation FL865UT
SMART BUY FL862UT ABA Z400 TWR W3520 Desktop Computer
SMART BUY Z400 TWR W3503 Desktop Computer
HP Z600 Desktop Workstation FL869UT
HP Z400 Desktop Workstation FL860UT
HP TouchSmart IQ804 KT457AAR ABA Desktop Factory Recertified Black
HP Pavilion P6310F Desktop PC Black
Compaq Presario CQ5320F Desktop PC Black
HP Pavilion MS225 18.5 Inch All in One Desktop PC Black
HP Pavilion Slimline S5310F Desktop PC Black
HP TouchSmart 300 1020 20 Inch Black Desktop PC Windows 7 Home Premium
Compaq Presario CQ5300F Desktop PC Black
HP TouchSmart 600 1055 23 Inch Black Desktop PC Windows 7 Home Premium
HP TouchSmart 300 1025 20 Inch Black Desktop PC Windows 7 Home Premium
HP TouchSmart 600 1050 23 Inch Black Desktop PC Windows 7 Home Premium
HP Pavilion A4310F Desktop PC Black
Compaq CQ4010F Black Desktop PC Windows 7 Home Premium
AOPEN AMERICA INC. 791.ADE01.I210
Velocity Micro NoteMagix M15 GT
Computer Associates AVP10OEM100NA
Acer AS1810TZ 4008 Olympic Edition
Acer AS4810TZ 4183 Olympic Edition
Velocity Notemagix M10 Gx Burgundy
Canon Digital Rebel XTi Black 18 55mm Kit
Fuji FinePix Z37 Blue Bonus Bundle
Fuji FinePix Z37 Green Bonus Bundle
Fuji FinePix Z37 Purple Bonus Bundle
Canon EOS 5D Mark II 24 105 IS
Nikon S70 Champagne Light Brown
Canon SD430 Digital ELPH Wireless
Cheap LCD TV
Cobra GPSM 7700 Technology Fujifilm Finepix J38 Canon s90is Sony BDP-N460 Canon SD940IS Axion AXN-8905 Samsung UN55B8500 Shopping Online Flash GamesCheap LCD TVs samsung un46b8500 Garmin Oregon 550 Olympus FE-46 Olympus Stylus 7010 Cheap Garmin GPS Cheap IPOD Classic Cheap IPOD Classuc Accessories Cheap IPod Deals Cheap IPod Nano IPod Deals IPod Touch AccessoriesSony PSP Technology
Zune MP3 Players Samsung Ln40B650 Shopping Online Toshiba 47ZV650U Garmin 855 88T
Samsung LN22B350 Samsung LN65B650 Samsung UN46B6000
Canon SD940IS Canon s90is Nikon D3S Sony BDVE500W Panasonic SC-BT300 Pioneer Dv-420vk
Denon DBP4010CI Toshiba 19LV610U VIORE LED22VF60 Fujifilm Finepix S2100hd Samsung Ln40B650Cobra GPSM 7700
Zune MP3 Player Handheld GPS Cheap Subwoofers DVD Recorder IPod Nano Accessories
hamilton beach food processors Emerson Slc195em8 cheap lg 37lh30
cheap lg 42lh40 samsung ln19a650 samsung ln19b360
samsung ln22b460 samsung ln26b360 samsung ln32b360
samsung ln32b530 samsung ln32b650 samsung ln37b530 samsung ln37b650 samsung ln40b530 samsung ln40b550 samsung ln40b650 samsung ln46a750 samsung ln40b650 samsung ln46a750 samsung ln46b550 samsung ln46b650 samsung ln52a630 samsung ln52a650 samsung ln52b550 samsung pn50b450 samsung pn63a650 sony kdl-32xbr9 toshiba 15lv505 toshiba 19av500u toshiba 22lv611u toshiba 40rv525r coby tfdvd1574 coby tftv1022 coby tftv1923 garmin 1200 garmin 1250 garmin 1260t garmin 1300 garmin 1350 garmin 1370t garmin 1390t kodak z1485
lg electronics 42pq30samsung pn58a650 samsung pn58a760 samsung pn63b550 samsung ln46b530 sharp lc32d47usharp lc32db60u sharp lc40e77u sharp lc26sb24u sony kdl-52v5100 sylvania lc225sl9 toshiba 22lv505 toshiba 23hlv87 toshiba 26av502u-20 toshiba 26lv610u toshiba 32av502u toshiba 37av502r vizio va19l vizio vo32lf vizio vp505xvt discount cookware sets cheap digital photo frames canon fs200
canon sx200is canon sd1200is garmin 855t kodak m380 olympus fe-5010 olympus 7000 samsung sc-dx205 cheap ipod nano krups espresso machines olympus fe-3000 samsung smx-f34 samsung bd-p1600 toshiba 42av500 Panasonic SC-BT300 Sylvania LD195SSX Viore LED22VF60 Olympus PEN E-P2 VIZIO VM230XVT ViewSonic VT2430 Acer AOD250-1197 Acer AOD250-1197 Acer AOD250-1584 Acer AOD250-1694 Acer AOD250-1842 Acer AR1600-U910H Acer AS5542-5462 Acer AS5738-6969 Acer AS1410-2497 Acer AS1410-2039 Acer AS5738Z-4111 AKG K 242 Apple iMac MB950LL ASUS G51J-A1 ASUS K50IJ-X8 ASUS UL30A-A2 Eviant T7 Sony Alpha DSLRA850 Cheap IPod Touch Fujifilm FinePix Z30 Samsung HMX-H104 Garmin Edge 500 Magellan RoadMate 1424 Panasonic DMC-GF1 Samsung HMX-R10 Samsung HZ25W Samsung N140-14B Brother HL-3040CN Brother MFC-495CW Brother MFC-9320CW Canon VIXIA HF S11 HD Canon XH-A1S Casio Exilim EX-G1 Casio Exilim EX-Z90 Panasonic HDC-HS300 Samsung SMX-K40 Sony BDP-CX960 Cobra GPSM 7700 Denon AHD1001K Denon S-32 Denon DBP4010CI Fujifilm FinePix S2000HD Hoover UH70210 HP Mini 110-1125NR HP Pavilion DV7-3060US HP G61-320US HP Pavilion DV6-1350US Logitech Webcam C500 Magellan RoadMate 1424 Nikon TC-20E III Nikon TC-20E III Opteka OPT15 Panasonic AG-HVX200A Panasonic HDC-HS20 Panasonic Professional AG-HMC40 Panasonic Pro AG-HMC150 Pentax K-7 Polaroid DVF-130TC Polaroid CAA-330RC Panasonic DMP-BD60 Panasonic HDC-TM300 Samsung N130-13B Samsung N130-13P Samsung CLX-3175 Samsung SMX-K40 Sony DPF-V1000 Sony HDR-FX7 Sony KDL-52XBR9 Sony DPF-D72 Sony HVR-HD1000U Supersonic SC491 TomTom XL 340S Toshiba Mini NB205-N230 Toshiba Mini NB205-N325BL Toshiba Mini NB205-N325BN Toshiba 19LV610U Toshiba Mini NB205-N325WH Toshiba Mini NB205-N330BL ViewSonic VA2323wm Viore LC22VH55 Viore LC32VF55 Viore LED22VF60 Viore LED24VF60 VIZIO VA220E Vizio VA320M VIZIO VBR100 VIZIO VM230XVT VIZIO VO320E
Thank you for providing this
The damask rose.
Plastics, economics, and value
response to robiodo
Hi, I agree with most of what you're saying. The three R's are great, and even better when used. I think when people say plastic is evil, or better yet when I say plastic is evil, I'm referring to it's current state. It would be better if we could make a plastic that was really biodegradable. It would be great if we could make plastic that wasn't so toxic to life as we known, the toxic contents within plastic as we know it today are responsible for almost all of our cancer related problems, as well as some studies that point to these toxins contributing to our obesity epidemic, type 2 diabetes, and a large amount of birth defects. The bottom line is that we need a better plastic, one that's not killing us off, along with the world around us. If you're interested you should check out these links:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O1NNIx8Mc_k
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=watbi_vU3SA
a better hierarchy?
packaging
We must learn to accept many
The World is Changing
It's not paper and not plastic
The article details the problems with plastic bags and also the problems with paper. The responsible solution is for consumers to use reusable, washable cloth bags and for stores to sell food in ways that does not require packaging standardized portions into containers. Like all grocers did in the past and Farmer's Markets do today.
___
Web Design in Los Angeles
Los Angeles Web Development
Green Plastic Bottles
Between biodegradable plastic and eco friendly plastic bottles which just use less plastic, how much more greenwashing are we going to take?
plastic will start to
plastic will start to disappear i hope so. its so bad for the environment. When i go to the store they do not offer it unless you ask which is a good thing.
tiffany jewelry
of tiffany jewelry on ebay are cheaper than tiffany jewellery outlet store, why is that?
You will find the newest tiffany jewelry on sale fashion release on their official website.
I am planning to give my wife a big surprise with tiffany and co as a birthday gift, but I don’t know which one to choose, any ideas?
We are providing all kinds
We are providing all kinds of louis vuitton handbags, wallets and purses in ourgucci Online Store, all items of which have the most popular styles and are the newest and at discounted prices.
We also provide helpful shopping guide tips for you to choose and compare our bags and other accessories. Get your sale of replica handbags today and you will never be disappointed with it.
I would like to buy uggs,
ugg sale,
ugg boots uk,
ugg boots london,
ugg boots sale,
uggs,
ugg london,
ugg boots sale,
UGG Bailey Button boots,
bailey button ugg boots,
UGG Nightfal boots,
and so on.
I would like to buy uggs,
ugg sale,
ugg boots uk,
ugg boots london,
ugg boots sale,
uggs,
ugg london,
ugg boots sale,
UGG Bailey Button boots,
bailey button ugg boots,
UGG Nightfal boots,
and so on.
Ugg Boots
Uggs
Ugg
Ugg Sale
Uggs Online Sale
buy uggs
Buy Ugg Boots
Buy Uggs
Buy Uggs Online
Cheap uggs
Cheap ugg boots
discount ugg
discount ugg boots
Australia UGGS
Australia Ugg Boots
ugg bags
UGG Sheepskin Boots
Wholesale UGGS
Wholesale Ugg Boots
UGG Onsale
Ugg classic cardy
Fashion Ugg Boots
Fashion Uggs
uggs outlet
Classic Ugg Boots
winter ugg boots
Classic Argyle Knit Ugg Boots
Classic Crochet UGG Boots
Classic Ugg Boots
Cardy Ugg Boots
Mini Ugg Boots
Tall Metallic Ugg Boots
Tall Ugg Boots
UGG Classic Short Boots
Ugg Metallic Boots
Kids Ugg Boots
Sandals Ugg Boots
Amelie Suede Sandals Uggs
Coquette Sandals Ugg Boots
Dakota sandals Ugg Boots
Gypsy sandals Ugg Boots
Halendi sandals Ugg Boots
Morocco sandals Ugg Boots
Tasmina Braid Sandals Boots
UGG Tasmina Sandals
Sundance II Ugg Boots
Ugg Bailey Button
UGG Fluff Flip Flop
Ugg Nightfall
Ugg Stripe Cable Knit
UGG Sundance Grab bags
Ultra Ugg Boots
Ultra Short Ugg Boots
Ultra Uggs
buy ugg
buy ugg boots
buy uggs
buy cheap ugg
buy cheap uggs
cheap ugg boots
cheap uggs
uggs outlet
ugg outlet
ugg boots outlet
ugg boots
wholesale ugg boots
discount ugg boots
ugg boots on sale
ugg boots for sale
Post new comment
MoJo Comments: Send Us Your Feedback
We changed our spam software to better filter comments. Should you encounter any issues, please let us know.




