Bobby Jindal's Stimulus Lies
Bobby Jindal, the Republican governor of Louisiana, gave the GOP response to President Barack Obama's speech to Congress Tuesday night. I'll leave the analysis of how Jindal did to David Corn, but it's important to note that Jindal repeated two fairly common Republican lies about the stimulus package. Here's the relevant portion:
[The stimulus includes] $8 billion for high-speed rail projects, such as a magnetic levitation line from Las Vegas to Disneyland, and $140 million for something called "volcano monitoring".
The truth is that the stimulus bill does not allocate any high speed rail money for specific projects. In fact, any stimulus money for high speed rail would be allocated by Obama transportation secretary Ray Lahood—a Republican.
The 'volcano monitoring' part is almost as misleading. According to ProPublica, the relevant portion of the stimulus money is for "U.S. Geological Survey facilities and equipment, including stream gages, seismic and volcano monitoring systems and national map activities." It seems obvious that employing geologists, building facilities, buying equipment, and paying people to map the country all have a stimulative effect. But more importantly, why does Bobby Jindal think monitoring volcanoes is a bad thing for the government to be doing? There doesn't seem to be any immediate way for private enterprise to profit from monitoring volcanoes (maybe selling volcano insurance?), but there is obviously a huge public benefit from making sure volcanoes are monitored: warning people if a volcano is going to erupt. Isn't that obvious?
Apparently not to Bobby Jindal. But, of course, Bobby Jindal is the person who just tried to tell the nation that the problem with the government's response to Hurricane Katrina was that bureaucrats demanded that people have proof of insurance and registration. It wasn't.
(There's no money in the stimulus to save the San Francisco salt marsh mouse, either.)
UPDATE: You want a cool video on maglev trains? You got a cool video on maglev trains.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Comments
Bobby Jindal needs some education about volcanic hazards
What's wrong with a LA-LV rail project anyway?
So either he's trying to
Are you ensinuating that
Bushwacked Science
You are in the minority
Socialism is anathima to the American People
This is a joke right?
LOL, great post Deane. Just
Saying it repeatedly doesn't make it more true.
The polling I have read had
Get your facts first
Tax cuts for the wealthy?
"Why don't you Democrats
"[The] top 1 percent pays only about one-quarter of federal taxes."And don't forget that in addition to paying the most taxes, the super rich also make the most money. Doesn't sound like such a bad deal to me. "This is a center right nation" Says who? How did a center-right nation just elect an alleged Socialist? It's not like this was a bait and switch; he stated explicitly in his campaign that he would end Bush's tax cuts for the wealthy and cut taxes on 95% of Americans. And FWIW, I'm pretty confident Lincoln would be a Democrat if he lived today. His opponents were the ones looking to abolish the federal government.
No more Reagonomics.
RE: Socialism is anathima to the American People
top 1% pay 90% of taxes?
What?
Volcanoes vs Hurricanes
"I find it interesting that
Necessary Function of Government
I respect your opinion, but
Volcano Research
"However, (and this is the
Bobby "Vindaloo"(c) Tyndal & Jesus
Interesting to see you all
There is enough money in the
You should look at what's
Spend, yes, touristas, no
Volcano monitoring
There are more more than 750
Oh really?
Yes, REALLY
Another good source, if you
Umm...Part Two...
Ummm...sorry to correct you, BUT...
we care what THE EXORCIST has to say?
Good article
What I think!
Wait a minute...
MORE "LOW INFORMATION" VOTERS!
So tell me how will spending
The "Small Business Owner" meme
Jindal isn't accepting this
Who is this 'Anonymous' person who is posting so much?
Post new comment
MoJo Comments: Send Us Your Feedback
We changed our spam software to better filter comments. Should you encounter any issues, please let us know.



