Are Twitter and Facebook Bad for You?

| Tue Apr. 14, 2009 12:52 PM PDT
twitter-300x200.jpg

Obsessed with Twitter and Facebook? Then you're probably immoral and stupid.

At least, that's what two new studies claim. USC researchers allege that speed-tweeting leaves no time for compassion. I wonder if this applies to recent-Twitter convert Jesus. (Apparently, Twitter may also have jumped the shark. Poor Biz Stone.)

Meanwhile, a survey by Ohio doctoral students reveals that Facebook users get inferior grades in school. Because stalking ex-boyfriends online totally cuts into study time.

Somehow, I doubt these studies will stop anybody from social networking. Which reminds me: Did you know MoJo has its own Twitter feed and Facebook page? Check them out!

Advertisement

Advertisement

Nikki Gloudeman is a senior fellow at Mother Jones. For more of her stories, click here.

Get Mother Jones by Email - Free. Like what you're reading? Get the best of MoJo three times a week.

Comments

Twitter & Facebook

I understand the what the study is saying. I would agree with the fact that people who live on their computers throughout their teens (questionably having the largest impact on our social development) would probably suffer something. It's important to keep a balance of reality to computer time, weather you use Twitter, Facebook, or anything else. http://www.whatpercent.com/what-percent/hobby-technology/computers/176

Twitter and Facebook are great for research!

I just think that the academics haven't joined the trend. I bet a lot of these students were super-social prior Facebook. Balancing social time online and in the real world can be a challenge for some students. I'm just surprised teachers haven't encouraged student to start using Facebook to start discussions or after-school interest groups. Twitter can also save on group research time (use a hashtag to find the latest research or to mark a group discussion and updates). Social software is not positive or negative for students or teachers--its just online tools. Social software's use depends on its users.

I understand the USC

I understand the USC research about twitter and facebook being bad but it really does not make sense in reality. How do you figure speed-tweeting leaves no time for compassion? Perhaps these people were already like this prior to twitter. But how do you prove something like this? You cannot, that is why the USC research is bogus. Everything in moderation.

Facebook...

As with all things in life, balance is key. While it's certanly a lot of fun to spend time on Facebook, etc., it's just not healthy to spend hours and hours doing this. My only big complaint with Facebook is their arbitrary and Draconian system of disabling users who have violated some arcane little rule, without warning users of this beforehand.

But....

tagged as: 

But it is still fun right!!I mean I love it!LOL

For those of us who suddenly

For those of us who suddenly find ourselves far from home near no one we know, and who can't afford to pay for a social life (and this is the reality--if you don't have money you don't go to movies, don't go out to restaurants, don't go to theater, etc.--most people find parks boring anymore, and libraries want you quiet), the Internet is a godsend. And I never would have found so many like-minded people had I not had the assistance of social networking and search engines. For that matter it makes it very, very easy to find friends with whom I've fallen out of touch, long-lost family, people I went to high school with and liked back then but lost touch with, etc. Any time a new communication technology comes up we see a change in brain processing. I'm sure illiterate indigenous people from rich oral traditions believe that literate people are morons. Why? Because we can write down important information, so we don't have to remember it anymore. You take an indigenous person still in their traditional culture who learns from oral tradition, remove them from their immediate tribal environment and drop them in wild surroundings with familiar plants and animals and they will probably survive long enough to get back to their village or camp. Try that with an average American, no matter what grade their reading level. So... there are trade-offs. The key is to hold on to your humanity no matter what. Someone who uses social networking to have positive social interaction experiences rather than, say, to bully a teen girl into suicide has got the right idea.

I actually find myself

I actually find myself having to be more tolerant because of facebook because I now have such a varied collection of friends that it includes many people I have serious philosophical/political disagreements with. It makes me mindful not to be too terribly snarky about any certain topic, and because they are, in theory, my friends, it keeps me from being snarky in response to opinions expressed that I would normally be snarky about. In that sense, it's a reminder that friendship can overcome vast differences.

What a crap article. An

What a crap article. An overly provocative title with little to no justification. Thanks for wasting my time MJ.

Facebook is a slot machine

I found it as a one armed bandit that was constantly stealing time. I was asked to join by a family member and soon became a member of an extended family of wall writers that consisted of folks that I had no idea who was who. Who opinions I did not share or even care to hear about and pictures that provided the fact that the owner could afford an IPhone and point it. My background in technology started with vacuum tubes and my first program was written for a memory that had only 256 locations so the present gismos are simply amazing. Maybe I am just stuck in a rut as I can take my dog for a walk without telling everyone on Facebook that she took a crap.

Fast vs Deep

People who find social life taxing & tiring often go online to communicate because it doesn't require instant response time. You can carefully think out what you want to answer, and in the process learn from it. In the real world (today, not 100 yrs ago), people don't take the time to carefully form answers, they're too impatient to get somewhere else. Being thoughtful used to be a great asset in life, 100 yrs ago. Not today.

Networking Wisely.

I am a socially active, straight A teenager that has both a Facebook profile and a MySpace account. (Sounds ancient, but MySpace is far more interesting than Twitter.) I average roughly an hour a day on the internet and that includes not only social networking, but also homework, gaming, research and news reading. While an hour seems like a lot of time for someone who is only sixteen, I don't feel as if it cuts into time that I should be spending with friends and family. As long as any time spent on the computer is done constructively and not in excess, I don't believe it's possible to develop a lack of compassion or a slip of grades.

Facebook Twitter vs Texting && Email

tagged as: 

I feel as though the research done in this article is inaccurate. For I myself is addicted to twitter and it doesn't effect the way I live my lifestyle nor my grades in school. I have plenty of friends that are constantly on facebook and even more on twitter and they are graduating with honors. You cant say that if you havent been on the site, other then catching up with your friends & the latest celebrity gossip, twitter is also good for business such as networking. Its a convenient way to text everyone at once. So does that mean texting & emailing also effect students grades?

Very good article. I was

Very good article. I was recently blogging on The Netflix Prize, which deals with the quality of the recommendation. However, conclusions are drawn primarily off of user ratings. People don't seem to bother rating on facebook, I know I don't. I wonder what correlations exist there...

Post new comment

Alternately, you may login to or register an account
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <ul> <ol> <li> <blockquote>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

MoJo Comments: Send Us Your Feedback

We changed our spam software to better filter comments. Should you encounter any issues, please let us know.

Photo Essays

The chaos and humanity of war.
A selection of '70s ads depicting African-Americans.
As climate change melts the permafrost, native villages slip into the sea, taking a way of life with them.
Colombia's first environmental film fest.